54 Comments

OMG! You are so wonderful to use E Jean Carroll's story to re-create a favorite cake! I'm going to make this, after I obtain things like milk and cream, and I'm going to pay attention to the maternal-like nag because ... that is so kind of you. And as for "our E Jean" well, I believe that she was intimately invaded against her will and she deserves double the amount of punitive and compensatory damages. Love to both of you extraordinary women!

Expand full comment

And back at you!

Expand full comment

Can I have a slice?

Expand full comment

You can have two!

Expand full comment

I’ve been looking for a white cake recipe and none of them looked appealing but THIS one looks like a winner and I am thrilled to be able to bake a cake in solidarity to celebrate E Jean!

Expand full comment

TBH I would always choose chocolate cake....but this vanilla cake changed my mind.

Expand full comment

Wow, this cake looks wonderful, will try it and share. Mom made a chocolate custard cake for my birthday. She’d melt the chocolate squares in a double boiler top then add to the batter. She died before we could talk about it, had no idea where the recipe was till I opened a recipe book my just deceased sister had made for me - and there was the recipe. I think it’s finally time to try making that cake. Thanks for what you do, Marissa. Blessings to you and E Jean both.

Expand full comment

Please make this cake. Happy to try the recipe too, if you want to send it through. It sounds delicious. What a wonderful memory. So glad the recipe exists.

Expand full comment

Pulitzer prize for your sister.

Pull-it-surprised for you.

🍰🎂🥧🎄☃️🧘🌌🌞🙏

Expand full comment

I'm so happy so happy so happy!!! Wish I could give E Jean and her whole legal team a giant hug and a THANK YOU and CONGRATULATIONS!!!!!! Cake looks neat too :)

Expand full comment

Agree. Hugs all around.

Expand full comment

The fact that it took the jury less than 3 hours to reach unanimity not only on the verdict but on the amount of damages is even more delicious than this cake - though the cake sounds truly wonderful even to this lover of dark chocolate.

Expand full comment

I, too, was surprised by the speed with which it was decided. It says a lot about the evidence and how wonderfully Robbie K argued the case.

As for chocolate cake, with all due respect to E Jean, I prefer it too. However, this cake, esp the frosting, made me appreciate vanilla more than ever.

Expand full comment

If any occasion calls for cake, this one does! Happy judgment day (not THAT judgment day) to E. Jean Carroll, and to all of us who have been waiting for even a taste of judgment (but no cake) to land at the feet of you know who!

Expand full comment

Yes, yes, yes!

Expand full comment

Freaking fabulous! Aww <3 Congratulations E. Jean! The truth is neither Liberal or Conservative, the truth is the truth.

Expand full comment

Applause, applause for E Jean Carroll and the result! Love to you, Marissa, for this recipe. Sentimental attachments to our childhood cakes loom large for many of us. I loved yellow cake with chocolate frosting (though my mother’s cakes usually leaned perilously like a Disney cartoon!). My daughter’s favourite has always been marble cake with chocolate frosting and butterfly decoration.

What is yours?

Expand full comment

I hope you have photos of those fun sounding cakes. I should make more marble cakes. Haven't made one in ages. As for me...for a longtime, my favorite cake was from Trost's in Summit: chocolate cake, vanilla frosting in the middle and...mocha frosting on the outside. Oh how I wish Trost's was still in business. For all that I could bake just about any cake, nothing matches Trost's for pure joyful memory.

Expand full comment

Ooh! That sounds wonderful! I love mocha. No pics of my mother’s cakes, sadly, but yes on all the butterflies (and a Barbie!). My daughter has an Instagram for her cakes “tinycakesuk” because she has picked up the cake bug!

Expand full comment

What a way to celebrate the courageous E. Jean Carroll. I am making these as cupcakes and delivering to my many women friends.

Expand full comment

Love the idea of making as cupcakes and sharing with your friends. Post a pic on my Twitter if you can!

Expand full comment

Thanks to E. Jean & the anonymous jurors who thought it more likely than not that the perpetrator did it. B/c this was not a criminal case. the jury did not have to find beyond a shadow of a doubt. judge recommended that the jurors remain anonymous for a long time.

Expand full comment

This sounds delish. I was all ready to give it a go but I’m short on eggies. How did that happen? Oh I know - I’ve been too busy celebrating E Jeans victory. Yay!

Expand full comment

Looks delicious. Will bake and enjoy this in celebration for E Jean. So happy for her!

Expand full comment

I'm sure she'll appreciate it!

Expand full comment

Such a wonderful post! Am so very happy for E. Jean and her legal team to have achieved some justice. Extraordinary.

Expand full comment

I’ll make this soon. But I’m confused about the pans...the recipe says you’ll use 2 pans...you say there are 3 different pan sizes you could use. Could you use 2 round cake pans?

Expand full comment

Sorry for any confusion. Yes, use 2 pans of the same size. Just adjust the cook time according to size!

Expand full comment

Yum! Thank you so very much!

Expand full comment